Rodin’s Debutante is a bust

I saw that Ward Just’s new novel, Rodin’s Debutante was on President Obama’s summer reading list, and since it had a Chicago setting, I decided to read it myself. I found the book to be disappointing, so my advice to you, Mr. President, is if you haven’t got around to it, skip this book and go on to another on your list.

The early part of the book takes place in the fictional New Jesper, an industrial town located north of Chicago on the shore of Lake Michigan. It seemed to sound like Waukegan, but I was never clear if Just meant it to be Waukegan, since nothing definitive of the town’s identity ever emerged from the story’s narrative. Then the book moved to Chicago’s South Side, Hyde Park and Woodlawn, where I didn’t feel the writing encompassed the personalities of these Chicago communities.

I thought that the characters in the novel were cliched, the actions predictable and the language prosaic. The protagonist Lee is someone you don’t emphasize with, in a book that is trying to mimic, in writing and tone, the cinematic ambience of Orson Welles’ great film classic Citizen Kane.

There was nothing, in fact, great or classic about Rodin’s Debutante. With apologies to the sculptor Rodin, it is a bust in the literary sense.


1 thought on “Rodin’s Debutante is a bust

  1. I’ll take your word for it and I won’t bother with this book. However, while reading this post, I wasn’t exactly sure what a “debutante” was, so I asked my friend Wikipedia and got filled in. I came to learn that Chicago had the “Big Four” debutantes around the time of WW I. If I had the choice to marry one of the four, I would have to choose Edith Cummings because she seemed to be an adventurous person with many exciting hobbies (big game hunter, equestrienne, pro golfer, etc.). I was undecided between Cummings and Courtney Letts (voted one of the world’s top ten best-dressed women), but in the end I chose Cummings because she seemed to be the total package. To the fellow bloggers: which one of the “Big Four” would you marry and why?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s